When solving the ball paint puzzle, Garry has to head into the Doll Room to find the final ball of paint, which is the white one. It behaves as it does in the pull cord room. In the Tree Library, there is another rare sighting of Red Eyes peeking its head over the bookshelves.

If the player chooses to kick the doll, it will be decapitated, and Garry's doom counter will increase by one point. At the end of the hall, the player can chose to have Garry either move the doll out of his way peacefully or to have him kick it. It will communicate with him through wall writings and will ask Garry to take it with him. Later, in a winding hallway in the Violet Area, a teleporting doll will follow Garry as he makes his way to the next area. It will look from side to side, then laugh, before disappearing. There is also a chance of a blue doll dropping down when the rightmost cord is pulled, adding one point to Garry's doom counter.

In the room with the pull cords, there is a rare sighting of Red Eyes peeking its head over the wall. Garry will comment on how he doesn't understand how anyone could see the dolls as 'cute.' The Red Eyes painting has gone from a rabbit to a doll, the shelves are lined with dolls in different clothes, and large variation of dolls hang from the ceiling, nearly decapitated.

In Garry's perspective, it is revealed that the room of bunnies is actually full of dolls.

The first encounter with the blue dolls can occur when Garry is searching for a way to reunite with Ib and Mary in the Violet Area, specifically in the room where Red Eyes resides.

Ib the game mary freakout